We've been discussing a lot lately, (in class and on the blogs) about the aspect of philosophers who incorporate a deity to answer questions which seem to lead to no logical answer. Obviously, for those who rigorously and logically analyze theories, this can be problematic. My question is this; what should be done? I would like to think that some of the greatest philosophers that used God, or some kind of metaphysical mystery to convey an idea (Kant, or Aristotle's unmoved mover, etc) could not possibly conceive a better way in which to explain their theory.
Should theories that reach this point be thrown out? Published for further criticism and advancement? Or can their be a silver lining of truth in a theory that takes this form?
I will be commenting on this on my blog
ReplyDelete